Featured Post

A Knock Or Ten Thousand On The Head

Peter Keating wants to know why no one cares about female concussions:

Women suffer more concussions than men in the sports that both play, with an injury rate 50 percent higher, according to the most recent research. Female athletes with brain trauma tend to suffer different symptoms, take longer to recover and hold back information about their injuries for different reasons than males. Anyone involved in sports should have a grasp of these key facts. Yet the leading national and international guidelines for understanding sports concussions and returning injured athletes to play ignore key differences in how women and men experience brain injuries.

Here’s what’s even more stunning: All of that information was public knowledge eight years ago, when ESPN The Magazine first looked at the subject of concussions and female athletes (“Heading for Trouble,” March 23, 2009)-and all of it is still true. The latest studies continue to find that women get brain injuries more often in sports also played by men. But research into why and how is lagging to nonexistent, as are efforts to reverse the trend. Which means millions of female athletes are putting their brains at risk unnecessarily.

“More and more of the athletes I have seen over time are young women, and I’ve found they get less information about concussion from their coaches, and from the media too, than men,” says Jill Brooks, a clinical neuropsychologist who runs Head to Head Consultants in Gladstone, New Jersey, and who in 2004 conducted one of the earliest research reviews of sex issues in brain injury. “They are struggling to deal with their particular symptoms and often not being taken as seriously as they should be. The sports world is much more accepting of girls and women as athletes but still gives the topic of their concussions short shrift.”

concussion photo

Image by Lorie Shaull A Knock Or Ten Thousand On The Head

It’s a really good article, and one that I think about as we talk about getting our daughter involved in sports. We need to learn how to take care of our female athletes. I think there’s a bit of a lose-lose situation here that may prevent it from being publicized: We don’t want this to be true. We don’t just want this to be untrue for reasons similar to not wanting it to be true for the NFL, but we also don’t want it to be true because we don’t want to discourage girls from sports, or to feed notions that they don’t belong in it. And more broadly, it draws attention to concussions that occur elsewhere.

It’s one thing – even if a very uncomfortable thing – when we’re talking about how to deal with concussions in a single sport played almost entirely by men. Worst case, no more sport. But really, we’ll probably just expect men to tough it out and give them some better equipment. But a concussion problem over all sports? Affecting females in particular? That will send discouraging messages. It shouldn’t, because there is a continuum of risk, but people don’t understand continuums of risk very well. Especially not when we’re talking about children. Doctors do seem somewhat sensitive to the possibility. In other words, be concerned but not too concerned:

As for athletes and their parents? “Take a deep breath,” he said. “If you’re concerned about sport concussion, the best thing to do is to talk to your health care provider, such as your school’s certified athletic trainer, to understand what is currently being done to assess your child prior to, following and throughout recovery from a concussion. If absent, request a pre-injury assessment based on clinical measures of cognition (memory, reaction time, information processing), balance and symptoms.

“Also, discuss who is involved with your school’s concussion management team and the roles that they play. Parents should be aware of what resources are available to better inform themselves about concussion. If an informational session is being held about concussion or other injuries, plan on attending.”

For now, football is the only sport that has too much to worry about. It’s the only major sport that seems troublesome not for falling the wrong way or some stroke of luck, but playing it to begin with. What I am most interested in is the effects of football in K-12, and to an extent college. That was why Aaron Hernandez’s post-mortem diagnosis was so alarming: He wasn’t in the NFL very long at all.

It should also be pointed out that there are a lot of intermediate steps that can be taken. Only a very small proportion of the contact occurs in games. There are – depending on the level – usually anywhere from 8 to 16 games a season. They last anywhere from 32 minutes to 60 minutes of play. The majority of that time is spent walking or standing around in between plays. The average college or NFL team takes between 60-70 snaps, fifty or so for high school, and that’s about it. At the high school level you do have some players on both offense and defense, so it’s more for them. The number of plays falls dramatically for middle school and youth sports.

Meanwhile, if my own football experience is any indications, practice is a long series of repetition of hits. One. After. Another. There is no clock management, no moving up and down the field. There is less time resting while the other team (offense if you’re on defense, defense if you’re on offense) takes the field. Historically, some teams do recognize the risk of injury and have some pad-free football practices. But even if they avoid some injuries, they risk a competitive disadvantage. A former coach at my school did this and it showed in our performance (particularly in the area of tackling) and when he left for another school he stopped doing it. The Ivy League has limited contact practices to twice a week. Given the competitive elements, it’s something that the NCAA and high school associations around the country are going to need to look at. But if there is a solution to be found, there is a better chance it’s there than it is with calling penalties on certain hits.

The worrisome part, of course, is that we won’t know what works until it’s too late (if it doesn’t work). Either way, I think football survives as a major sport (if not the major sport). What talent we don’t cultivate here, we will bring in from elsewhere to do the jobs Americans won’t do.

Next year starts a new professional rugby league, and we have two expanding lacrosse leagues, though I expect both of them are more likely than not going to suffer from the association with football (the ecigarettes to football’s regular cigarettes). An advantage of lacrosse is that unlike football you can have men’s teams and women’s teams, but that just brings us right back to the issues at the top of this article.

Home Page Twitter Google+ Pinterest 

Will Truman is the Editor-in-Chief of Ordinary Times. He is also on Twitter. ...more →

Please do be so kind as to share this post.

12 thoughts on “A Knock Or Ten Thousand On The Head

  1. As an MMA fan, I worry about the wave of CTE cases that is about to arrive. The pioneers in the sport are now all in their late 40s. The sport was much less injury-adverse in the early days and their fights looked much like the old Tough Man contests where two guys just hit each other repeatedly until the one of them lost consciousness. These early MMA fighters will undoubtedly start showing signs soon. Proof? The case of Jordan Parsons is a good example. Age 25, MMA fighter for 8 years and killed tragically in a car accident. They studied his brain and he had CTE. I struggle sometimes with the ethics of enjoying a sport where I know this is happening.

      Quote  Link


  2. An advantage of lacrosse is that unlike football you can have men’s teams and women’s teams, but that just brings us right back to the issues at the top of this article.

    Is the insinuation here that some/all of the gender differences are a result of player-to-player collisions in co-ed sports? ‘Cause the article seems to avoid offering context, but this quote suggests it might be:

    In gender-comparable sports, so sports that both boys and girls play, by the same rules, using the same equipment, on the same fields, like soccer and basketball, girls have higher concussion rates than boys.

    EDIT: The distinction I’m making is between sports injuries caused by the equipment and those caused by another player.

      Quote  Link


    • That was not my intended insinuation. It was mostly that while women can play lacrosse, if they are more susceptible to head injury and maybe that’s one in particular they should avoid. (I assume lacrosse has more head contact in part because of the gear they wear.)

        Quote  Link


      • OK, and I may have misinterpreted same sport/rules/field as necessarily having anything to do with co-ed play.

        I’ve watched a lot of youth soccer, and don’t recall any potential concussions from heading the ball, but have from either head-to-head contact or tumbles to the ground. My suspicion is that by around age 13, at least in co-ed soccer, girls are likely to get the worst of contact with boys due to emerging differences btw/ height and upper-body mass.

          Quote  Link


  3. My vague memories of lacrosse (I did not play but helped manage/scorekeep for the women’s team one year) from prep school was that women’s lacrosse was WAY less physical: I don’t remember helmets being worn like the men wore (but then again, this was the mid 1980s, before helmets were such a thing in many sports). There was some checking and “pushing,” but there weren’t (as I remember) full-on collisions.

    I came to think of lacrosse – from my experience with the women’s team – as being like “airborne field hockey,” though I guess field hockey can get kinda physical. (My main experience with the physicality of field hockey – the one year I played – was getting my shins badly banged up by other player’s sticks, even with shinguards)

    Maybe we make all lacrosse more like old-school women’s lacrosse? (shortie-kilt uniforms not necessarily required). Or like “stickball,” which is a thing here among people with Choctaw and Chickasaw heritage? It’s pretty physical in the sense that you have to be fit and coordinated to play it, but there seems to be a lower risk of concussion….

      Quote  Link


  4. There is a bill in Illinois to ban tackle football under 12, which has provoked a lot of slipper slopes argument, though I agree with Will here:

    if my own football experience is any indications, practice is a long series of repetition of hits.

    About five years ago my daughter’s soccer team shared a practice field(*) with a youth football team, about 10-11 years old. It was mostly drills involving bodies hitting bodies. I assume that aspects like passing and receiving were for special sessions. The national youth soccer association has banned heading balls for ages 11 and under, but heading is generally a limited aspect of youth soccer anyway.

      Quote  Link


  5. Being officially involved in sport fencing, athlete safety comes up regularly. Concussions do happen, almost always by falling badly and hitting the unpadded floor with the back of the head, but are rare. Whiplash is actually more common, when a straight lunge hits someone flush on the mask unexpectedly and snaps their head back. The most common injuries are to joints: sprains, strains, and occasionally the worse stuff. And bruises, of course. At least for an epee fencer, dime-sized bruises here and there are a way of life.

      Quote  Link


  6. My son was removed from a game for concussion concerns once; I think it was from multiple trips that sent him head to ground. The curious thing I remember was what happened after listening to the medic explain why they were taking him out of the tournament and how we should monitor him for the next 24 hours to make sure there wasn’t a concussion injury for which he would need to seek medical care.

    The coach turned to my wife (not me) and asked if she had a problem with any of that? Nope. The coach said good; we’re taught in coach’s training that the moms are the most difficult to sell on this, and I could tell you stories about the moms. My wife’s response was “no, I love my son.” I’m curious about these stories and what dynamics they suggest, but I know of none even indirectly.

      Quote  Link


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *