This week, our assignment was to watch the two episodes “The Equation” and “The Dreamscape” from Season One of Fringe. (You can read the Television Without Pity Recaps here and here, while the AV Club has their recaps of the episodes here and here. The post dedicated to the Pilot episode is here and the subsequent episode posts are here, here and here.)
As always, here are the ground rules: nothing that we have seen so far is considered a spoiler, anything that we have not yet seen should be considered a spoiler. Crazy nutbar speculation is *NOT* a spoiler, but confirming or denying said confirmation would be.
Here’s my idea for spoilers: please rot13 them. That’s a simple encryption that will allow the folks who want to avoid spoilers to avoid them and allow the people who want to argue them to argue them. We good? We good! Everybody who has seen the two episodes, see you after the cut!
Ah. An opening to the show that is okay to eat during.
I suppose it’s just as well, however, because if you’re yelling at the television, you won’t enjoy your food either.
So the guy not only pulls over to help the lady in distress, he looks under the hood? This is one of those capers that has too many points of failure for me. I mean, I don’t know if I’d pull over in the first place (caper fails right there) and, if I did, I’d call for a tow on her behalf and I’m outta there. It’s not like the dad is even a mechanic. This is writer-fail, here. If the dad was a mechanic in his day job (and how hard would it be to have him be one?), you have just explained to a schlub like me why he was inclined to pull over and help. It’d be like if they had a lady on the side of the road saying “one of my file systems won’t mount and it was mounted before the power outage!” and I could see pulling over and saying “well, we just need to run a fsck on hey, what are these green and red lights?”
Maybe the fact that he’s a widower (we establish that in a couple of scenes) is sufficient… I guess…
Anyway, we have ourselves a kidnapping.
During the briefing, we find that we have ourselves a pattern that may be part of The Pattern (“maybe we should have called ‘The Pattern’ something else”, the writers casually mention in the breakroom). Folks have been kidnapped before, they show up a few days later, and they come back insane… but they all mention the lady and they all mention the green and red lights.
One thing we find out is that Ben is a musical savant following a coma. Hrm. For only one song. Hrrrm. And, yeah, dad’s a widower. Hrm. And the the mom’s death was related to the coma Ben fell into. Hrrrm.
Walter, of course, worked on green and red lights back in the 70’s. The work was, of course, highly theoretical. He wasn’t able to get them to do what he wanted them to do but, I’m sure, he left enough notes lying around for anyone inclined to pick up where he left off… and we see him demonstrate on Peter that this week’s phased cationic pulse can not only make him black out, but, in a really, really funny scene, it’s demonstrated that Peter can be made to follow suggestions to do things like cut off his sleeves. (This is one of the things that you’d think that they’d bring back down the road. Spoiler through first 8 episodes of Season Three: gurl qba’g.)
Thanks to the dad’s description, we’ve got a positive ID on the kidnapper who is, of course, legally dead and has been since about eight months prior to the first kidnapping. Well then.
Walter remembers, through a series of leaps that I think are supposed to be funny but sound like they could have come from a story told at one of my family reunions, that he had a friend back at the asylum who told him about the red and green christmas lights. Road trip! Except, of course, it seems that the guy is a “1027”, which means “criminally insane with knowledge of state secrets”. Is that a thing? (Googles… No. It, apparently, is not a thing. I mean, I’m sure that it *IS* a thing, it just doesn’t seem to be a thing to the point where they’d have a number designation for it in real life.)
Hrm, apparently he was obsessed with an equation to the point where he killed his wife over it. We have pictures.
We have a brief interlude where we see the kidnapper, kidnappee, and mom.
Everyone else looks at the pictures and is horrified by the body. Walter, of course, notices the equations all over the wall. Luckily, the television in the corner is showing the kidnapped little boy playing that song he’s obsessed with… and the equation could be rephrased in musical notation… right? Sure! And how could they both the boy and Walter’s friend have been working on the same equation? We establish that “Curious minds often converge on the same idea.” (This is one of the things that you’d think that they’d bring back down the road. Spoiler through first 8 episodes of Season Three: gurl qba’g.)
We jump back to the kidnappee and mom and he asks if this is heaven. This is how the writers set up “pulling the rug out from under everybody”.
We jump to the asylum and are now talking with William Sadler (WOO WILLIAM SADLER!). Is he going to be a new semi-regular? (Spoiler through first 8 episodes of Season Three: ab.) As it turns out, William Sadler is irritated that Dr. Bishop had been removed from the hospital and refuses to let Olivia talk to Walter’s old friend… Walter, however, can come back and ask the questions on Olivia’s behalf… (note: it’s a trap)
So now we jump to Olivia and Peter arguing in front of Walter about whether Walter is going to go back, however temporarily, to the asylum. Walter shows a surprising amount of fortitude by saying that every minute wasted is another minute of danger for the boy… and, yes, he’s going back. Good for him.
Walter and Dash sit together and Dash is eating the butterscotch pudding. Awesome. It doesn’t take long before we start a riot and have Walter thrown back into his old cell. Walter, Olivia, and Peter are the only people who seem surprised by this.
We go back to Walter in his room and we see Walter come in and say “Welcome Back, Walter”. I admit to thinking “my god, they’re going to do a switch of the two Walters” when I first saw this episode. (This is one of the things that you’d think that they’d bring back down the road. Spoiler through first 8 episodes of Season Three: gurl qba’g.) As it turns out, this is just a hallucination on Walter’s part.
We can’t get Walter out without a Court Order and we can’t get a Court Order until tomorrow. Bummer.
So now we get a scene with Peter and Olivia where, for the first time, Peter’s past really gets established. They always told us that he was a conman but they never really *SHOWED* us that he was a conman. Until now. He explains how most folks use aliases and explains how he used stuff like “Peter King” and “Peter Knight” instead of “Peter Bishop” and figures out that the kidnapper, Joanne Ostler, was likely to use names like Joanne Hyatt and Joanne Ritz (which, of course, gets a hit immediately). This is an example of good writing.
We jump to Joanne Ostler in the basement with the kid and mom and we see the leash yanked for the first time. Mom starts bleeding from the face if the kid can’t finish playing the song.
Back at the asylum, we see Walter extract the explanation that the woman promised everything the person ever wanted… but then took it away when the equations couldn’t be solved… and we cut to Ostler and the kid. The kid is hooked up to a bunch of diodes all over his head… and we cut back to find that these things happened in a red castle… which is then dismissed as the rantings of a loon. Sigh. This is one of the heralds of bad writing.
We see Peter and William Sadler engage in some light alpha male bravo sierra before picking Walter up who talks about how his friend ranted like a loon about red castles.
We call Olivia who is turning up red herrings and she takes a call from Peter who makes a joke about red castles.
There is, of course, a red castley looking thing behind Olivia as this phone call takes place. She turns around. She sees the red castle. Sigh.
She and Charlie go inside, there are hallways with exposed pipes and everything and they split up. Sigh. Olivia finds the boy with all the diodes taped to his head… and Ostler is in there too! They fight to a stalemate (rot13 for Maribou and anybody else who has made it through all of Season One: erzrzore jung V fnvq nobhg Wbua Fpbgg’f svtugvat fxvyyf riraghnyyl oyrrqvat vagb Byvivn’f fxvyyfrg? Guvf vf jung V’z gnyxvat nobhg urer) and Ostler is outta there. Olivia gives chase, Ostler turns around and presses a button.
Christmas lights.
Charlie wakes Olivia up (that particular plot point getting used one last time was a nice touch) and we cut to see Ostler bring a notebook to the guy who had the parasite! The mole! I suppose I should look up his name. Mitchell Loeb.
Mitchell Loeb has an apple, a safe, a computer, and some wires. Loeb locks the apple in the safe and set up the wires on the back of it… while he gives a speech about how numbers run everything, he pulls the apple through the wall of the safe. Seeing that what he did worked, he shoots ostler in the chest. Dang. He makes a call.
The show ends with the kid and the dad being reunited in the FBI offices which should make us sigh in relief… though I personally would have swapped the last two scenes around, myself… given the next episode.
The next episode is, of course, The Dreamscape. In this episode we OH MY GOSH THERE’S THE OBSERVER.
Where was I? Oh, yeah. A harried guy runs into a meeting room where everybody is ticked that he’s late… we jump ahead a little bit to see him close and everybody who was ticked is now really, really impressed. Everybody leaves the room leaving harried guy there to clean up. Harried guy then notices a little moth in the room which, when it flies next to him, cuts him. After a fight that involved harried guy being cut on the neck (OUCH) we finally slap the moth down and confirm that the wings are, in fact, razor sharp. We then see two more moths fly out of a grate and around him and then the guy LOOKS DOWN THE GRATE instead of throwing his jacket over it. Of course, a swarm of moths surround him and begin to cut him to ribbons… he runs and jumps through the window down, down, down into the parking lot. Next to the parking lot is a sign.
Massive Dynamic.
Of course.
Olivia, who is apparently getting all dolled up for a group date gets interrupted by a phone call telling her to show up. “I quit”, she says. Broyles tells her where to show up. Olivia ceases getting dolled up.
She shows up at the parking lot where Walter is noticing that while there are many cuts from the glass, there are other cuts underneath the shirt (and there are no cuts on the shirt). (An aside: this should have been my first clue. I spent the first 20 minutes watching this show and waiting for them to talk about the moths again.) Olivia sees John Scott in the crowd.
Olivia interviews Nina and Nina offers Olivia a job again. Why? What is Nina hoping that Olivia won’t end up finding working at Massive Dynamic that she will at the FBI? (Or vice versa?) After offering the job, Nina explains that some of the people they hire can’t take the stress and jump out the window. Which is not the best “come work for us!” speech I’ve ever heard. Anyway, we’re now searching Harried Guy’s house and finding that he had an impressive array of medications and he collected butterflies (or, at least, had them on his wall). Maybe they weren’t moths in the first scene. Maybe they were butterflies. We also find a plane ticket for something coming up soon which tells us that, no, he probably didn’t jump out of depression. Wait, it’s a ticket for Nebraska. Maybe he did. Olivia finds the word “Monarch” in a day calendar and looks up at the butterflies on the wall which start flapping their wings.
Walter is being Walter back in the lab but the takeaway is that the wounds came from within and the guy was on an impressive amount of medications. Peter gets a phone call from an old… let’s say it’s an old girlfriend from his conman days. They set up a meeting.
Olivia is googling butterflies (see??? butterflies!) and goes to bed to hear her computer reboot. She gets up and finds an email from John Scott on there and it gives her an address. (Now here’s what I’m wondering: is the email real or is it from her subconscious? If it’s real, who sent it (if it wasn’t sent by her)?)
We go to the address and find all sorts of things there… including frogs. What the heck?
We go to Charlie and find him wondering what the heck is the deal with the frogs. You and me both, Charlie. Olivia pulls Charlie aside and asks for some PTO (at my job, if I am called in for an emergency while I am getting all dolled up, I get PTO automatically). The phone rings and Astrid tells us that the guy jumped out of the window because of the frogs. (It is at this point that I realize that I will never again hear about the moths/butterflies from the first scene.)
Peter and the ex are in a diner. She opens with “you look older” and that reminds Peter of Walter saying “I thought you’d be fatter” and she expresses surprise that he saw his father. What this quick scene did was establish that Peter spent a *LOT* of time complaining about his father during his conman days. We establish that the ex hangs with a rough crowd that feels it has a score to settle with Peter. Peter feels likewise.
Back to the lab and we see Super 8 footage from the 70’s where Walter has a guy under a psychoactive drug and we go on to see Walter technically not exactly torturing him, kinda. Walter is holding an ice cube. The wigged-out guy is convinced that Walter is holding a hot coal. Walter touches the guy with the ice cube. The wigged-out guy blisters. What does this have to do with the frogs? (“Toads.”) Well, they secrete a drug that can act as a phased cationic pulse and make the drugged person actually physically respond to a fear stimulus as if something were “really” happening. So Harried Guy would be cut all over his body, for example. No moths required. “So whomever these frogs belonged to may be the killer.”, Olivia says. The frogs, of course, belonged to John Scott. She and Walter discuss this and Olivia wants John Scott out of her head. This, of course, involves… The Tank.
Peter is stalking his ex? Creepy.
We now hammer out what going back into The Tank is supposed to do. Olivia is seeing John because part of his memories crossed over in the Pilot episode. They’re part of Olivia’s subconscious now. By bringing them to the surface, she can expell them. This involves LSD. Of course.
With the help from Astrid reading from scripture (I think this was to allow Walter to give the line that he was religious once but he’s not anymore), we guide Olivia to a memory of a restaurant… her first date with John. She watches them interact and watches dream Olivia get up and go to the bathroom or something. Real Olivia sits in the booth and rambles about love for a second before letting the cat out of the bag. “Mark Young (Harried Guy) killed himself yesterday.”
AND JOHN LOOKS RIGHT AT HER EVEN THOUGH THEY’RE IN A DREAM.
They flash to a different memory. She’s at the railyard and she sees John Scott, Mark Young, and two other guys. Mark Young runs off in that direction with one of the other guys, John Scott stabs the other other guy… and this freaks Olivia out and she aborts out of the tank.
Facial reconstruction software allows us to recreate the face of the last of these guys who are still alive (Hey! Why didn’t they interrogate the butterfly guy?) and we hammer out that this was likely a sale of this weapon-grade LSD on the black market. Nasty! After a brief interlude where Peter stops stalking his ex long enough to beat up her boyfriend (dude, that’s not going to help in the short, medium, *OR* long run), we see that Nina has delivered all a heavily expurgated number of Harried Guy’s files… and something rings a bell and she digs out the day planner and dials “MONARCH” on a telephone… which connects us to the last of these four guys still alive.
Thanks to the resources of the FBI, we get the info on this number, it’s a cell phone, it belongs to a guy named Morales, and he’s a high-end dealer on the black market. This calls for a chase scene! The scene ends with Morales being hit by a car and taken to a hospital where he demands immunity and protection from Massive Dynamic… and, in exchange, he’ll talk about *EVERYTHING*. He says that he didn’t kill Harried Guy, Massive Dynamic did. He didn’t come up with ZFT, Massive Dynamic did.
Olivia is *STOKED*. She leaves her star witness alone to tell Nina all about the awesome stuff that is going to happen once he testifies.
Meanwhile, back at the hospital, we see John Scott walk into Morales’s hospital room… and proceed to kill him. The nurse walks in and watches Morales in there, all by himself, but his throat opens up as if it were opened by a knife.
Awesome scene. Not for the violence, but for the terror that John Scott inspired. The scariest thing in Morales’s mind? John Freakin’ Scott.
Anyway, Broyles calls Olivia and chews her up this way and down that way for yelling at Nina. Oh, and to tell her that the witness is dead.
We cut to the bad side of town and Peter’s ex tells a guy who looks like a conman’s associate that “Peter Bishop is back in town.”
And we go back to Olivia getting ready for bed just in time to get one more email from John Scott which says: I SAW YOU. IN THE RESTAURANT. (Seriously, who is sending these?)
The show is doing a great job at this point of establishing an internal mythology, setting Walter up as “just crazy enough”, Peter is finally establishing his streetwise chops, and Olivia is having some seriously weird things happen to her. Massive Dynamic is establishing itself as The Evil Corporation, Broyles is establishing himself as a boss who can only cover for so much, and John Scott is the scariest dude on the planet. I am seriously digging this show.
So… what thinks did you thunk?
I liked both episodes. The main thing I liked about the Equation was the scene of Walter talking to himself. It really brought his insanity and the fear of it to life for me. He also seemed to act differently after being picked up and that was a nice touch.
The main annoying thing in this one was the phased cationic pulse in the lights. This really simple one could be used quite a bit, but I doubt we see it again, just by how Jaybird was talking about it. Also, why is a trained agent getting her butt kick and some dumb lady? Sigh.
The second episode also had a good moment where they revisit the pulse used in the first episode. I liked that, finally the show remembers what it did in the past. I also love the moment the John Scott’s memory looked at Olivia.
The two things I did not like about the episode was our smartest dumb guy award going to Peter. He has made a point in a few episodes saying that he should not be in Boston and needs to lie low, but now he goes and announces to the the very people he was hidding from?? Second, now we are back to thinking the Massive Dynamics is just another “Evil Corporation”. Still, that could become a plus in my mind if they can keep jerking me back in forth on how I view MD.
gurl qba’g
Gbb boivbhf.
I enjoyed The Equation – it was kinda X-Filesy.
Joanne seemed so wooden I half expected her to be another projection or maybe a robot/alien/observer.
The stuff with Walter back in the asylum was great, predictable, but great. The spolier makes me sad.
Were we supposed to know what he’s doing with the apple? This is one of those things my wife always asks and normally I tell her ‘keep watching and they’ll tell you sooner or later’, less confident this time.
Dreamscape was awful, beginning to end.
Trying to come up with something good . . . nope.
The apple was locked in the safe. The equation, once pumped through the wires, allowed him to reach through the safe and pull the apple through the “solid” safe wall.
No spoilers but this is explained in more detail next week.
I liked the Dreamscape, if only because of the absolutely perfect first five minutes.
That still gave me a dimensional feel. Maybe because I just finished watching JL: DOOM and the Royal Flush gang had used a dimesional shifter at the beginning to walk through the wall of a bank and that became even more relevant at the end.
Keep watching!
I agree the Dreamscape was probably the weakest episode so far. The main reason I was okay with it is to bring back John and MD into the storyline and advance it a bit.
I’d say that “The Same Old Story” was the weakest we’ve seen so far (and if not that one, “The Arrival”).
Given the seeds planted for future shows (you won’t *BELIEVE* the opener for next week’s show), “The Dreamscape” cleans up quite well.
Funny, I found the Arrival to be one of the best in my mind.
I didn’t watch Episode 7 (In Which We Meet Mr. Jones) until this week, so I’ll just note here that it is awesome. Although that’s the second time the Olivia’s gone to extremes to save someone’s live only for them to turn out to be a traitor; given how close the person in question came to dying in each case, I think the bad guys are relying a bit TOO heavily on the skills of Our Heroes. The combination of Olivia’s old relationship in Ep. 7 and Peter’s in Ep. 9 seems to be building parallels that could lay the foundation for a relationship between the two. (Also, I don’t trust Olivia’s friend in the Bundestag; I’ll be interested to see whether he shows up again).
The Equation is one of the best episodes yet, and provides Walter with some wonderful character development. It’s a bit jarring to see him so invested in this case when, in the previous episode, he was obsessing over favourite foods while an FBI agent was dying, and seemed more interested in studying the parasite than saving the man’s life. (And, on another Ep. 7 note, comparing the parasite to Giardia made me roll my eyes. If you’re going to compare it to something, a tapeworm or flukes is much nearer the mark, as the creature is clearly multicellular; and it’s not like “parasite” is some obscure piece of terminology that you need to define, anyway). Back on Ep. 8 – maybe Walter’s concern in this episode is because it’s a child that’s been kidnapped. (Znlor va fbzr frafr ur’f gelvat gb ngbar sbe univat xvqanccrq Crgre.) Anyway, his devotion to the case and his slow regression when trapped in the asylum have a lot of emotional resonance.
Dreamscape, in contrast, made me want to hit my head against the wall. I have a fairly high willingness to suspend disbelief in science fiction, but this episode wasn’t even science fiction. If they said flat-out “it was magic”, it would be more believable. No, you can’t get burns, or millions of incredibly sharp cuts, or get your freaking throat slit, just by THINKING it’s happening. What’s next – a guy dreams he’s falling and wakes up with all his bones broken?! There actually has to be a physical stimulus to cause physical damage! If you get cuts, there actually has to be a real object cutting you! Your imagination does not make it real! Seriously, if you’re going to have some kind of “fear chemical” killing people, go with something like the one in Batman Begins, which actually makes a comparative amount of sense (death or madness directly through causing terror)! It’s plausible that a person can die of fear. It is not plausible that a person can die of imaginary butterflies. Seriously, did the writers get into some of Walter’s drugs when thinking up that episode?
I also wasn’t a fan of Peter’s subplot – it didn’t seem at all relevant, and didn’t seem to tell us anything useful, and that’s not an effective way of dealing with an abuser anyway – it’s not as though Peter can monitor him 24/7. I am, though, a big fan of the John Scott subplot. Olivia can’t be sending herself the emails, so he’s either actually still alive/around or it’s a combination of someone posing as him (the emails; meaning they’re from someone who overheard her saying she thought John say her in the memories) and Olivia’s hallucinations/errant memories. Intriguing.
Your imagination does not make it real!
The part of this that drove me mad was not the psychosomatic nonsense (it seemed in keeping with plenty of the pseudoscience we’ve already seen), but a failure to establish a mechanism by which the particular imaginings happen at all.
Sure, the dude collected butterflies, if you give the dude a hallucinogen – why would he invent razor-winged butterflies that want to attack him? Maybe he’d just dream regular ones that flit around. Clearly, in Walters little film, the subject was being led rather directly to the idea that he was being burned.
Then, why did the mounted butterflies flutter at Olivia? Was she exposed to some of the drug but only a teeensy bit?
I think that the butterfly flutters were a hint from John Scott.
Agreed, I think that was a John Scott hint. I agree about the butterflies though. He liked them, why would he be deathly afraid of them?
A couple more comments on Dreamscape:
– Broyles’ reluctance to consider foul play on MD’s part is inexplicable. When a key witness offers to testify against a powerful party, and that key witness mysteriously dies, the party is question is obviously the first and major suspect, regardless of presence or absence of physical evidence. Also, after promising to protect the guy, Olivia’s an idiot for immediately going to the people he was going to fink on and telling them he’s going to do so, especially without first moving him to a safer location.
– Also, the toads thing bugged me. Most chemicals can be synthesized in a lab these days, even ones that naturally occur only in plants or animals, and it’s a lot less traceable to do things that way rather than importing animals. The contrast between the supposed super-advanced “fringe” science and an inconsistency like this is annoying. If you can build all the crazy stuff MD does, you can synthesize a simple chemical. (Shows like this device, especially sci-fi shows; I remember an episode of Babylon 5 where there was a serum that could grant immortality, but the only way to get the components was to kill other sapient beings. If a society’s advanced enough to have spaceflight, they’re certainly advanced enough to produce the components synthetically.)
When it comes to Broyles, I saw that as evidence that he couldn’t exactly be trusted either. This goes part and parcel with his withholding of important (even essential) information. “We want you to solve this half of the mystery. The nice part with children and puppies.”
I alsi felt the Broyles part was significant. Remember he was on the secret commity with her. It would not surprise me if they have worked together a lot and he has baggage in that area.
Yeah, the Broyles thing made sense to me in that light. The Olivia thing was dumb – when I complain about bad writing this is what I mean, they fail to find a good way for the events to come about naturally so they just make the character do something inexplicably stupid to move the plot where they want it to go.
I wish that in Dreamscape, the bruises were there but not the cuts. Or the cuts were self-inflicted (they thought that someone else was doing it, but they were themselves doing it). However, I am willing to forgive *a lot* for John Scott appearances. So I liked the episode in the overall.
On the Equation, it was interesting seeing Britta from Community in that role. I had to look her up because I couldn’t remember where I saw her from. Also, it was interesting to see Dr. Sumner appear so early. I had forgotten that he was an earlier character, in addition to a later one (I don’t think I’m spoiling anything by saying so).
I missed last week. The introduction of Mr Jones is pretty awesome. The Cure, and Loeb’s introduction, is one of the reasons I am looking forward to seeing the early episodes again.
If you’ve seen season 2, you can decode the following:
Jr’er fhccbfrq gb oryvrir gung gurl ner gur onq thlf. Bs pbhefr, vs gurl’er cercnevat Rnegu sbe gur vainfvba sebz gur bgure rnegu, gung zvgvtngrf guvatf. Ohg V pna’g erzrzore ubj gung jnf rire nqqerffrq, vs vg jnf.
Something to make you say “Whoa”. The John Scott from the last part of this show?
That’s the THIRD JOHN SCOTT WE’VE SEEN SO FAR.
Your recap of the episodes are almost as entertaining as the actual show.
Frick! I miss the observer every time. I’m glad your here to point him out.
I’m pleased you like them!